HSP
  • Home
  • Events
  • Product Book
  • Industry Case Studies
  • Subscribe
  • Contact us
  • Petition
  • Health
    • Asbestos
    • Chemicals (and COSHH)
    • Disability Discrimination Act
    • Ergonomics
    • Musculoskeletal disorders
    • Noise
    • Sickness absence
    • Stress/bullying
  • Safety
    • Directors' duties
    • HSE
    • Personal protective equipment (PPE)
    • Work at height
  • Professional Skills
    • Ask the recruitment expert
    • Management skills
    • Qualifications
    • Training
    • Training guides
  • Industry
    • Catering and leisure
    • Chemicals
    • Construction
    • Public services
    • Retail and distribution
  • E-Newsletter
Nexen receives 'wrist slap' for rig leak

01 March 2007


A £400,000 penalty for an offshore operator after a massive offshore hydocarbon leak that put rig workers' lives at risk has been criticised as too small by trade unions. No one was injured in the incident at Nexen Petroleum UK's North Sea Scott platform, but the HSE said it was only by chance that the cloud of gas did not ignite and cause serious or fatal injuries.

The leak happened on 5 September 2005 while two technicians were removing a pressure safety valve connected to the live pressure flare system. Following the initial release just after 11am, it took the company nearly eight hours to identify the disconnected valve and make it safe. More than eight tonnes of gas produced a huge cloud above the platform, causing Nexen to down-man 138 non-essential personnel.

HSE investigators found that the rig operator had failed to provide a safe system of work for the valve's removal.

Canada-based Nexen admitted breaching Section 2(1) and Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act for failing to ensure the safety of employees and others. At Aberdeen Sheriff Court on 24 January, sheriff James Tierney fined the company £200,000 for each offence.

Unions representing oil workers criticised the penalty, arguing that senior managers need to be brought to account. Amicus regional officer Graham Tran told HSW that anyone who believes this is "a just penalty" is not living in the real world. "This was a very serious incident that had the potential to be another Piper Alpha if it had ignited," Tran argued. "In the HSE's own words, it was only luck that it didn't ignite. Again a company goes to court and walks away with a slap on the wrist."

Highlighting oil firms' massive profits, he said a £400,000 fine is "not the answer to these unfortunately recurring incidents. We need proper accountability in the boardroom. It is no longer good enough to say lessons are being learned; they have to be learned. And with the safety statistics in the North Sea going in the wrong direction, you don't have to be a genius to work out that lessons are not being learned."

Comparing the £400,000 fine to "pitifully low" fines in the past, Jake Molloy of the OILC union said the Scottish judiciary does finally seem to be acknowledging the seriousness of such incidents. But he too believes that no fine on its own is a sufficient deterrent. He told HSW that senior management needs to be held to account in some way, which would provide a greater deterrent than just increasing fines. This might involve striking directors off the board or disqualifying them from holding other directorships.  


Categories:
Chemicals, Enforcement (prosecutions), Prosecutions, Enforcement (prosecutions), Work equipment

Bookmark this article with:

  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Propeller
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Yahoo
  • Technorati


Share this page

Printer-friendly version



  • Most read
  • Emailed
  • HSE unveils new poster
  • Forum pledges less construction bureaucracy
  • HSE to make ACoPs free online
  • Trainer's toolkit: all aboard
  • Trainer's toolkit: board games
  • Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act
  • Food Safety Act 1990
  • Control of Noise at Work Regulations
  • Surveyor failed to carry out asbestos checks
  • Student worker receives compensation for leg amputation
Latest News
RSS
HSE issues guidance for firefighters on balancing duties with risk
Government launches new wellbeing tool
Minister resists extending RIDDOR to work-related road injuries
HSE calls on industry to improve safety alerts
Rail regulator raises Network Rail maintenance fears
Employers urged to sign up to new MSD charter
What do you think?
Latest Articles
RSS
Multiplication game
British Sugar gets personal
Focus on careers: nerve tonic
Business
Industry Case Studies
Products and services
Find your next job here
2009 course directory
Events
RSS
17 March 2010: Managing a Healthy Workplace
23 March 2010: Butterworths Corporate Manslaughter course - Birmingham
25 March 25, 2010: Oil and Gas Technology Forum Drilling Day
Latest Jobs
RSS
H&s Consultants - Associates Required - Uk Wide
H&s Training - Associates - Uk Wide
Uk H&s Manager (london) Exclusive!
Senior Cdm Coordinator - London
She Advisor - West Midlands


HSW April 2010
  • Read current issue
  • Contact us
  • Subscribe










    HealthSafetyProfessional SkillsIndustry
    Asbestos
    Chemicals (and COSHH)
    Disability Discrimination Act
    Ergonomics
    Musculoskeletal disorders
    Noise
    Sickness absence
    Stress/bullying
    Vibration
    Asthma
    Display Screen Equipment (DSE)
    Drugs and alcohol
    Risk assessment
    Legionnaire's disease
    Accident reduction
    Enforcement (prosecutions)
    Mental health
    New and expectant mothers
    Older workers
    Safe systems of work
    Smoking
    Fire
    Directors' duties
    HSE
    Personal protective equipment (PPE)
    Work at height
    Road safety
    Risk assessment
    Corporate manslaughter
    Chemicals (and COSHH)
    Electrical safety
    Lifting operations
    Migrant workers
    Regulation
    Asbestos
    Confined spaces
    Accident reduction
    Accident reporting / RIDDOR
    First aid
    Safe systems of work
    Drugs and alcohol
    Emergency planning
    Enforcement (prosecutions)
    Insurance
    Lone workers
    Manual handling
    New and expectant mothers
    Noise
    Slips, trips, and falls
    Training
    Violence at work
    Work equipment
    Worker involvement / representation
    Workplace transport
    Young workers
    Ask the recruitment expert
    Management skills
    Qualifications
    Training
    Training guides
    Catering and leisure
    Chemicals
    Construction
    Public services
    Retail and distribution
    Transport
    Utilities
    Financial / general services
    Manufacturing / engineering

  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Reprint and Syndication
  • © Lexis Nexis. All Rights Reserved.

  • Partner sites:   LexisNexis
  • Magazines and Journals
  • Conferences and Training
  • Supplier Directory
  • Taxation Jobs
  • Taxation
  • Legal Jobs
  • Company Law Forum
  • Health and Safety
  • Health and Safety Jobs
  • Environment in Business
  • Green & Environment Jobs
  • Payrolls & Pension Jobs
  • Employment Law Forum
  • www.newlaw-directories.co.uk